The Pizza Party That Was Never Meant to Be

Welcome to the fourteenth instalment of my series where I test out recipes from an obscure 1990s Italian cookbook. This time, I tried pizza, which for some reason, is listed under the ‘Gnocchi & Polenta’ section

recipe test no.14: pizza

Sadly, my good luck streak with this book came to an abrupt end with this attempt which turned out more like a giant cracker than a pizza.

From the get-go, I had some beef with this recipe. The book recommends using plain flour which is quite literally a recipe for disaster – no pun intended. Strong flour is essential for pizza as its higher protein content gives greater rise and structure. This base, therefore, had little to no hold, resulting in a very brittle texture.

Yet again, I was trolled by unclear oven directions (a hot oven???), so my first attempt was burnt to a crisp. I tried my second pizza at a lower temperature and for a shorter time – the base was a nice golden brown this time, but it was still hard and cracker-like. Alas, this pizza party just wasn’t meant to be.

first attempt – burnt to a crisp

The only saving grace was the sauce, which was decent, but not good enough to redeem this disastrous base.

The only saving grace was the sauce, which was decent, but not good enough to redeem this disastrous base.


I split the base in two, but the recipe only advises on making one pizza which is supposed to serve 4 to 6 people. Maybe I’m just piggish, but I don’t think I’ll be hosting a pizza party with just one pizza anytime soon – I think my guests would politely decline any future invites.

FINAL RECIPE RATING: 4/10

I’m very sad not to be sharing a revised recipe with you this time but for now, I leave you with some pizza topping inspiration, if nothing else. I must say, Spanish ham, rocket, parmesan, and a dash of truffle oil are still a fantastic combination and would be even better on a proper base… 

Spanish ham, rocket, parmesan, and a dash of truffle oil would be even better on a proper base.

I always love hearing from readers, so if you have any questions or would simply like to connect, fill out the form on my contact page or message me through my social media accounts:

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *